Ranking Every Fall Out Boy Album from Worst to Best

Fall Out Boy has been one of the most influential bands in the pop-punk genre, captivating audiences with their catchy hooks and emotional lyrics for nearly two decades. With numerous albums under their belt, fans often find themselves debating which record shines the brightest and which ones might feel a bit less memorable. In this blog post, we’ll delve into each of their albums, ranking them from worst to best, and shedding light on what makes them unique. Don’t forget to check out the Fall Out Boy Store to grab your favorite albums and merch!

5. "Make America Psycho Again" (2015)

While a bold attempt to remix and reinterpret tracks from their previous album "American Beauty/American Psycho," "Make America Psycho Again" ultimately lands at the bottom of our list. This album features a collection of tracks reimagined with the help of various artists, but the effort often felt like a gimmick rather than a genuine evolution. While there are standout moments and creative instrumentation, it didn’t quite resonate as a full-fledged album. The experimentation is commendable, but it lacked the cohesion that fans had come to love from Fall Out Boy.

4. "Folie à Deux" (2008)

Released in the aftermath of their commercial breakthrough, "Folie à Deux" displays a band grappling with their newfound fame and the turmoil that comes with it. The album is filled with ambitious orchestration and multifaceted lyrics, showcasing a more mature side of Fall Out Boy. However, the mixed reception and less catchy melodies compared to prior works resulted in it being ranked fourth. That said, it still has its gems and holds a special place for fans who appreciate its experimental tendencies.

3. "American Beauty/American Psycho" (2015)

This album marked a return to the pop-punk roots that endeared Fall Out Boy to their fans initially. With a polished sound and compelling singles like "Centuries" and "Uma Thurman," "American Beauty/American Psycho" successfully blends bouncy pop melodies with rock elements. While some critics felt it strayed a little too far into mainstream territory, it undoubtedly contains tracks that have become staples in the band’s catalog. Its radio-friendly vibes and energetic feel make it a favorite for both new and longtime fans alike.

2. "From Under the Cork Tree" (2005)

It’s hard to argue against the impact of "From Under the Cork Tree." This is the album that propelled Fall Out Boy into the spotlight with their infectious choruses and relatable lyrics. Featuring hits like "Sugar, We’re Goin Down" and "Dance, Dance," the album captures the essence of teenage angst and heartache perfectly. It was an important milestone for pop-punk music in the mid-2000s, and its legacy endures. This album set the standard for what punk-pop could be, firmly solidifying Fall Out Boy's place in music history.

1. "Save Rock and Roll" (2013)

Taking the top spot, "Save Rock and Roll" marks a transformative period for Fall Out Boy. After a hiatus, the band returned with a more mature sound that showcased their growth both lyrically and musically. With collaborations featuring artists like Elton John, this album perfectly encapsulated a revival of not just the band's career but of rock music itself. The themes of perseverance, hope, and renaissance resonate through songs like "My Songs Know What You Did in the Dark (Light Em Up)" and "Alone Together." It’s an album that feels complete and undeniably powerful, reminding us why we fell in love with Fall Out Boy in the first place.

Whether you're a lifelong fan or a new listener, each Fall Out Boy album provides a unique glimpse into the evolution of one of the most beloved bands of the genre. Be sure to check out the Fall Out Boy Store for all the latest albums, merchandise, and memorabilia to celebrate the band's extensive discography!